Here's a more visual look at how you can set the options of individual forum to notify you when there's a new post or thread.
If the Forum Options dialog box shown below is not visible in the forum you wish to track,
click on the Options button to open the dialog box.

The Forum Options Dialog Form

Below is a blown-up image of the Forum Options only
In the Forum Options dialog box (at the bottom of the image above), you can set the options to Send E-mail to suit your own individual preferences
- Never - This option will mean the forum will not notify you of any new topic or post unless you set it at individual topic level
- When new topics are posted in this forum - This option sends you an email when someone post a new topic. Only new topics would trigger an email to you. Replies to an existing topic would not.
- When new posts are posted in this forum - This option will send an email to you whenever someone makes a post to the forum, whether it's a new topic or replies to existing topics.
Note: The 3rd option is what I normally set for forums which I take an active interest in.
CK Au (jack208)
Boardgame Meetup photos at Flickr Angkor Wat blog